(Hucka)been there, done that

Now the story told by yet another “Bible-believing” politician who thinks he is contributing something—and contributing something true.  Mike Huckabee, former governor of Arkansas and once a presidential contender, has produced a “historical” DVD that supposedly highlights God’s “love for our nation.”

But what is the nation to which he refers?  The ethnically identifiable “nation” of the scriptures was a different kind of entity from the “nation” of the United States.  We do have ethnic nations in our world today, but the U.S. is not that kind.  Often, the term “nation” is a synonym for “country”; at other times, “nation” symbolically signifies a group brought together by some other force, such as a college or professional sports team.  Many modern countries, including the U.S., seem categorically different from the Hebrew nation or the Philistine nation.  (See this post for additional pondering of the nation concept, drawing attention to the Christian identity.  Ironically, I’m probably more ethnically related to someone from Switzerland or Scotland than to someone from South Dakota, but I hardly feel nationally connected to any of those, and I would always prioritize my Christian nation.)

In any event, the yarn spun by Huckabee and lots of other “Christian conservatives” about the American nation is a yawn.  “God’s love for the U.S.” is an idea concocted out of thick air—thick with people who not only believe, but also blithely promulgate, the idea that God has especially guided the United States.  These people are almost as common as, and even more deluded than, those who think they can play the guitar.  God only has a role in American history in that He has been a factor, to whatever extent, in the individual lives of certain key figures.  But God has not been orchestrating historical events¹ in/for the U.S.A. as a country.  To the extent that Huckabee’s (or any other) history claims God’s protection of a modern country, it is off-base.


There is little more ideologically ridiculous than the idea that God would (now) love or protect one nation or country over another.  God is not about geopolitical entities.

It is conceited for a U.S. Christian to feel God’s special love upon his/her country.  What does this delusion communicate to someone visiting from Canada or Mexico?  And what about people from a country halfway around the globe (whether physically resident at home or here, as an alien)?  Are we saying God loves our country more than South Korea or South Africa?

It is wrong-headed to assert that God’s loves any country per se.  Rather than loving or championing countries, God loves people—for instance, those in Uruguay, Uzbekistan, the UAE, and the United States equally.

A probing question for philosophers or sociologists might be how, and to what extent, do geopolitical systems affect individual souls?  Theologians, in turn, might inquire at the nexus of God’s will, government as His “agent,” and a person’s response to injustice, and evangelists might ask what extent should Christians become involved in civics in order to affect individual souls?  Those are good topics that any thoughtful person might pursue, but the supposed guidance of God over the U.S.A. is a silly story, deserving scrutiny and even censorship by reasonable people, whether they are believers in God or not.  The story has been told far too often for its dubious merits.

Mr. Huckabee, I’m sure your intention was good, but your assertion that God loves our U.S.A. “nation” is as redundant as it is bogus.  We’ve been there and done that.  It’s high time for a new narrative, allowing more mature, more biblical (and even more appropriately patriotic) understandings to take root.

¹ I would assert that God did specially orchestrate some events for the ancient Jews for centuries, but the scenario then changed.  The Jews served their holy purpose roughly up to the time of Jesus and perhaps for a few more decades.  Then the destruction of the temple, etc., constituted a final cataclysm within that faith-system.  Ethnic Jews and the modern state of Israel are no longer of any specialized concern for God.  In other words, ethnic Jews and others in Israel today have the same standing as all other people in God’s eyes.


2 thoughts on “(Hucka)been there, done that

  1. Comments via my other blog:

    05/10/2018 / 4:51 pm

    John 3:16 responds to your comments, “For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.” Note “the world.” Given that fewer and fewer people in the U.S. are intentional followers of Christ, why would God consider U.S. a Christian nation? But remember, “a man convinced against his will, is of the same opinion still.” People will believe what they want to believe. ~~ Anne B.

    Brian Casey
    05/11/2018 / 7:32 am

    Hmm. The CACCV* renders that verse differently: “For God so loved the ideals of the framers of the U.S. Constitution, and perhaps almost as much those of the Pilgrims who came before, that He gave His only Son to serve posthumously as a banner for this democratic republic and the supposed “American Dream.”

    Whether there are fewer intentional followers or not (and I think you’re surely right), I know you and I both know the Christian nation isn’t geographically or politically defined.

    * CACCV: Common American Conservative Christian Version 🙂


  2. Comments via Facebook:

    Edward Wilson Many, maybe most people, in many countries believe that God and country are essentially the same thing. The German expression during world war two was Gott mit uns (God is with us). This idea goes along with all of the teeth gnashing associated with perceived abuse of the piece of colored cloth we call the flag. What I just said is not a very popular idea!

    My reply:
    Brian Casey This surprises me a little. You could be right. Are you thinking of far eastern countries as much as Catholic ones in Central or South America? And would you say the same about countries in West Africa? Maybe the more pertinent question is whether people connect God and country more often when the religious climate is more homogeneous, e.g., in Japan or the Middle East or India. Maybe I’m wrong in assuming it’s more homogeneous there….


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s